Can a Physical Therapist Perform Spinal Manipulation? How Does Manipulation Compare to an Adjustment?

October 19th, 2009

 

 

 

Easy answer to the first part of the above question – YES!  Yes, except if you live in the State of Arkansas??  (See #1 below)

 

Let me start by defining some words we are using:

 

Mobilization or manual therapy means a group of techniques comprising a continuum of skilled passive movements to the joints or related soft tissues, or both, throughout the normal physiological range of motion that are applied at varying speeds and amplitudes, without limitation.

 

Manipulation utilizes a high velocity, low amplitude thrust technique whereby the joint is moved beyond its normal physiological range of motion.

 

Adjustment  “refers to a wide variety of manual and mechanical interventions that may be high or low velocity; short or long lever; high or low amplitude; with or without recoil. Procedures are usually directed at specific joints or anatomic regions. An adjustment may or may not involve the cavitation or gapping of a joint (opening of a joint within its paraphysiologic zone usually producing a characteristic audible “click” or “pop”). The common denominator for the various adjustive interventions is the concept of removing structural dysfunctions of joints and muscles that are associated with neurologic alterations. The chiropractic profession refers to this concept as a “subluxation.” This use of the word subluxation should not be confused with the term’s precise anatomic usage, which considers only the anatomical relationships.” (2)

 

Now, back to the topic! The manipulation technique has been added to most curriculums throughout the USA. (Interesting topic found link #3 below)  The manipulation technique has been taught by most physical therapy curriculums external of the US for a long time.  Some physical therapists use this technique frequently; others, not so much.  Every Physical Therapist is different, but it is my opinion that a manipulation technique can be very beneficial when used with the correctly identified patient.

 

A question I often get from the public when discussing this topic is, “What is manipulation as compared to an adjustment that is traditionally performed by Chiropractors.  Here’s the skinny:

 

The easy answer is that both techniques usually involve the technique culminating with an audible “pop”.  The pop is referred to as a cavitation in the physical therapy world and is the result of the release of nitrogen gas within the joint.  This is where the similarity between the two end.  Once again, I’m not a Chiropractor so I will not speak for them.  (Read link #4 and #5 to see what a Chiropractor has to say on this topic.)  As for the field of Physical Therapy, the cavitation itself is not the purpose of the technique, just a byproduct of it.  The primary reason why a Physical Therapist uses this technique is to create mobility in an otherwise tightened joint. 

 

This is a brief overview on this topic, but hopefully it gives you some insight.  If you have any questions, please ask!!

  

1-  http://physical-therapy.advanceweb.com/editorial/content/editorial.aspx?cc=61582&CP=4

2-  http://www.chirobase.org/05RB/AHCPR/08.html

3-  http://www.chirobase.org/17QA/ptschool.html

4-  http://www.chirobase.org/01General/chirosub.html

5-  http://www.chirobase.org/01General/01General/placebo.html

BLACK ELBOW STRAPS: 2009 VERSION OF THE MID-90’S FAD - “TV TAPE”

September 24th, 2009

Odd title, let me explain.  Back when I was a student athletic trainer with Saint Louis University Athletics, it was my duty to make sure all athletes were able to perform their sport and that included the cheerleaders.  Before each home game during the basketball season, it would be my duty to tape the male cheerleaders’ wrists.  Although I’m sure this added some stability to the joint, I would always tease my friend that the whole purpose of the tape was so that he could write words on the tape so that when the TV would pan across them, he would be able to get a message across; thus I named the wrist taping procedure as “TV Tape”.

 

Now, move forward 15 years and we have a new trend that is now pervasive throughout sport.  That is the wonderful Cho-Pat.  The Cho-Pat and similar bracing devices are designed to reduce the stress on the tendons at various places on the body where a tendinitis could be present: namely the elbow and knee.  Now, I am NOT saying that tendinitis does not occur or not a problem that is present in many athletes; HOWEVER I am saying I have never seen a single case of bilateral triceps tendinitis ever in my clinical career.  Add that fact to the reality that many athletes are now wearing these devices on both extremities at the same time and I am left believing that this fad is not being used in manner of the originally intended purpose.

 

If you do a quick little search on the web, I believe my suspicions are confirmed.  One site had a few respondents who actually believed it was used for a sweat reducer of some type.  Another responded to that person and stated it did not work too well, however he was continuing to use it as it “looked cool”.

 

People, c’mon!  Really!!

 

Alright, here’s the theoretical reason as to not use it in this manner.  When tendinitis is diagnosed, a person goes through treatment which can consist of various types, medication, physical therapy, etc.  Based on NOT getting a result of back to normal after those treatments are used, it is then decided to use a “brace” of some type to assist the body in doing the action it is having problems with.  That is where the problem arises.  If you add an external device to assist your body to do what it itself cannot do, over time you have to theoretically weaken the body as it is not meeting the demand itself.

 

Get it?  Theoretically you are actually weakening your body if you are using a device intended to assist a person do an activity pain-free IF they were unable to do it without the brace.

 

That is where we’re at with this.  If you think it looks cool, great!  But let’s look at the bigger picture here!  A medical device should be used if a medical condition is present; not due to the improved aesthetics of using the device.

More On Runner’s Knee

September 10th, 2009

The following is a continuation of my conversation and recommendations to a patient dealing with runner’s knee. This installment also covers my thoughts on the use of supplements and contains a link to our website where you can get more information on Amerisciences, the supplement line we carry at Spine & Sport. Enjoy, and as always, please feel free to send me any questions you may have.

 LJ: So would you weight train one day and run the next and just keep the rotation up? Do I just keep on weight training or is this just something that I need to do initially? I’m just wondering if this is something that you have to keep on doing for maintenance or not. I will definitely add this to my workouts though.

Thanks for the advice and happy running.

P.S. What do you think about using a glucosamine supplement to help with joints? I am curious if these are worth my time to help lubricate the joints. They are an expensive supplement so I am curious if you think there is a benefit. I have taken the product Osteo Bi-Flex in the past and wonder if you endorse something like this.

 Dr. Beauchamp: You could add the weight training in your routine when it is convenient for you.  I do some of mine when/during/after running ie lunges squats calf raises and the rest in a gym.  I would recommend lifting throughout.  In about 8 weeks you could decrease sessions per week to 2 and that will maintain.

I agree with the use of a glucosamine product as some of my patients have had success with using it.  The fact of the matter is the source of the glucosamine is where the problem is.  The majority of people taking supplements do not understand that what is in the pill can be significantly different from manufacturer to manufacturer.  The pills you find on the shelf at a discount rate at a local large distributor may or may not contain what it states it does contain - as there is minimal to no oversight of that industry (supplementation businesses).  The company that I promote and use is Amerisciences.  It uses better-than pharmaceutical grade measures that insure quality products.  The product I promote for joint pain is Joint Ease; it is the best product on the market for that particular problem.  Here’s a link on our website: http://www.spinesport.org/home.cfm/page/products/category/0/product/36_Joint_Ease_(1_Bottle).html

Runner’s Knee

September 2nd, 2009

For the next few blog posts I am going to address a real issue that a patient is facing and share with you my recommendations. I hope you find this information helpful. Please feel free to send me your questions.

LJ: This is a fairly new pain for me that started after yesterday’s run. It isn’t even that much of a pain as it is an uncomfortable annoyance. It surrounds the knee on both of them but is mostly on the bottom to the inner part of the kneecap. There is a lot of cracking when I bend my knee, but that has been better within the past few hours. I’m guessing I just over ran yesterday, but I would like to know how I should treat it now. Is this due to weak surroundings around my knee? If so what would you recommend for building that up? I plan on resting my knee until the pain goes away (a few days) and then running a little shorter (6-8 miles). I am wondering if swimming with a kick board for laps would be good enough strength training or if you would recommend more? Or if I need to hit some weights (which ones), or running high resistance on an elliptical or something? I’m probably babbling here so let me know if I need to clarify anything.

Dr. Beauchamp: I agree, just sounds like you overdid it that day.  Strengthening would absolutely help in reducing this discomfort.  The best strengthening exercises to do would be some form of leg press/squat, lunges, knee extension, leg curls (hamstrings) and calf raises.  You would want to perform your strengthening exercises 3-4x/week doing 3 sets of 10-12 reps.  Swimming is good but does not give you the same benefit of weight lifting.

The other component is your running program.  Make sure you are not increasing your volume (running by distance or time) by > 10% per week.  If you do you significantly increase your probability of injury.  If you are new to running, you may even want to back that down a little more.

In the short term, you needn’t worry about the popping/clicking as it will go away with rest.  That usually is secondary to swelling (even very small amounts).  If the popping/clicking starts to get painful, that would be a reason to go and have a healthcare practitioner take a look at it.

 

 

Residency-Trained Physical Therapists

August 5th, 2009

A relatively new trend in the field of physical therapy in the US is Residency.  It models that of other doctorate-degreed professions in that it is training that occurs after the individual has graduated from physical therapy school and has attained a license to practice.  Usually the residency-site is geared towards a specific field of specialty, orthopedics, neurology, pediatrics, etc.  The physical therapist applies for acceptance into the program and upon acceptance goes through a pre-determined, rigorous training program that includes written, demonstration, working with an expert trained clinician along with a few other tasks usually while working as a physical therapist in the clinic. 

Yes!  Quite demanding, however quite rewarding if the PT is looking to improve his/her skills!  The residency can last anywhere from 6-24 months depending on how the program is structured.  Upon graduating residency, the PT is then able to market him/herself differently than other therapists as the knowledge and skills acquired on the residency path lead to significant knowledge in that area as compared to his/her peers that are not residency trained. 

Obviously, experience is also important and this writer is not inferring that a person with 10+ years experience is less of a therapist than one who is residency trained.  However, I am saying that a residency-trained therapist comes to the table with knowledge and skills that some experienced therapists do not have.

Another form of training that a PT can do after graduating is Fellowship training.  I will discuss that in my next blog!

Physical Therapist Training

June 29th, 2009

 

 I referred to the training a physical therapist has in my last blog.  Physical therapy has been going through a transition in the last 10 years.  Only 10-15 years ago, most PTs graduating from college received a bachelor of physical therapy degree.  It had been that way since our addition as a healthcare practitioner in the 50s (see the link: http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3969/is_200301/ai_n9302437/ for a history of where the profession came from).  Around 10 years ago, the physical therapy profession’s main association, the American Physical Therapy Association (APTA), released a document titled Vision 2020 (for more info, go to http://www.apta.org/AM/Template.cfm?Section=Vision_20201&Template=/TaggedPage/TaggedPageDisplay.cfm&TPLID=285&ContentID=32061). 

In it was outlined a vision as to where the profession was headed.  One of its many components was a doctoral level trained professional.  In order to make that vision a reality, the training of a physical therapist was going to need to be significantly increased.   To meet that demand, colleges and university programs slowly started transitioning from the bachelor degree of old to the doctoral level degree of today.  In 2009, most programs have made the transition.

So, what training does a physical therapist have?  Well, our training is quite extensive.  To see a list of courses that a physical therapist student takes, I took a sample of where I trained, St Louis University: http://www.slu.edu/x5774.xml.  It now takes around 6-7 years of training with some summer sessions to graduate with a Doctorate of Physical Therapy degree.  As you can see from the education, a physical therapist comes out of college with a solid foundation of how the body functions.

Another trend that we see in the profession is the move towards Residency Trained clinicians.  This is a relatively new concept in physical therapy and I will go more into what that means in my next blog.  Do you have any thoughts regarding a physical therapist’s training?  Was there anything that you were unaware of when you read this?

 

 

Direct Access

June 10th, 2009

In my last blog I stated I would discuss more in depth what Direct Access is.  Direct Access is the term used to describe a person’s ability to see a Physical Therapist without referral.  Presently in the US, 44 States and the District of Columbia provide the ability for any individual to see a Physical Therapist without referral. 

When discussing Direct Access I often am asked if the service is covered by insurance.  The answer is Yes!  Although various insurance plans have different rules and regulations, all you need do is verify your insurance benefits to find out what applies to you – which most physical therapy clinics do for you before you’re seen.  If you presently have an ache or pain and are wondering if a Physical Therapist would be able to help, please read the blog, “Should I See a Physical Therapist”.  If you still have a question, please ask!

In my next blog I will start the discussion as to whether or not a Physical Therapist has the training required to safely and effectively see a patient without a referral.  I look forward to sharing some facts with you!

Should You See A Physical Therapist?

May 6th, 2009

 

Who is an appropriate candidate for physical therapy?

That’s a question I often receive when someone finds out what I do.  A simple way to answer this for an orthopedic physical therapist is if you have pain that has changed (for better or worse) with movement.  It’s as simple as that. 

As physical therapists, we are trained in how the body moves.  That involves training in all the muscles, joints, tendons, ligaments, nerves, and many other structures of the body that are involved in moving.  When pain is made better or worse with any type of movement (i.e. having back pain and bending over creates more pain) then you should see an outpatient orthopedic physical therapist. 

In addition to orthopedics, which means injuries of muscles and joints, there are many other specialties that a physical therapist is trained in.  This can include neurological disorders, wound care, geriatrics, pediatrics, women’s health, and acute care to name a few.  A good resource to research all the different areas of physical therapy is at www.apta.org. 

If there are any physical therapists who practice in the different specialties, please add your response to the question to help people figure out what is it physical therapists actually do!

What do you want to talk about?

April 23rd, 2009

Why did I name this site “What Physical Therapy Is”?  I believe that is the heart of the question regarding our whole profession as Physical Therapists.  My intention with this website is to help develop a conversation about the many things that PTs do, who we are and what we are trying to accomplish.  The public for this webpage will be interesting as I have no idea who will find it.  My belief is it will be quite diverse - physical therapists, other healthcare practitioners and the general public who may have questions.  The topics that will be raised will be ones I come up with to begin with, but I’m hoping that many of the readers will also come up with some thoughts that we can all think and discuss.  So here’s my first question, “What topics pertaining to physical therapy do you want to talk about?”

Getting Started

January 19th, 2009

This will be the home of The Blog of Physical Therapy. Through this blog the intention is to shed light on all things pertaining to the practice of Physical Therapy. The content will be appropriate for people who have never had physical therapy, those who have, and healthcare practitioners who want to know more about what physical therapy is, what physical therapists do, who physical therapists are and what the APTA’s Vision 2020 means to you.